Local   |  Obituaries   |  Records   |  Engagements, Weddings, Anniversaries   |  Photo Galleries
Advertisement
Comment Email Print

Advertisement
Posted January 26, 2006

Speakers debate the pros and cons of Wal-Mart policies

By Nathan Phelps and Richard Ryman
nphelps@greenbaypressgazette.com rryman@greenbaypressgazette.com

Using Wal-Mart as an example of an American company paying less and providing fewer benefits to employees, the director of a local action group said it's time that issues like trade and health care move to the forefront of the political debate in the county.

While Mal-Wart is the example, they are not alone, said Nathan Sooy, Northeastern Wisconsin director for Wisconsin Citizen Action, as he addressed about 65 people Wednesday at the Brown County Central Library. The group held a town hall meeting on health care, jobs, trade and the 2006 election.

"Wal-Mart is hardly unique amongst companies, and that's the problem," he said. "Wal-Mart is encouraging … a race to the bottom in wages through competition for bad jobs" both at home and globally.

But an independent film producer, Ron Galloway of Augusta, Ga., doesn't view the so-called "Wal-Martization" of the economy as a bad thing. "There are a lot of good things associated with it. In the 1990s, Wal-Mart's efficiencies raised the productivity of the country and lowered the inflation rate," he said earlier Wednesday.

Galloway is the director of the film "Why Wal-Mart Works (and Why That Drives Some People Crazy)". It is seen as a counter to Robert Greenwald's "Wal-Mart: The High Cost of Low Price."

Sooy said the Wal-Mart example can be used as both an educational tool on issues — like health care and trade — and an impetus for change in the way politics are handled in the state and nation.

"Wal-Mart is the best example of the problem, but not its only practitioners," he said .

Galloway, who is also a member of the steering committee of Working Families For Wal-Mart, a group partly funded by Wal-Mart, said, "My big point of view is, the people that are protesting Wal-Mart are not the ones that need to shop there. People are voting with their feet."

This isn't the first time a company like Wal-Mart has come under fire, Galloway said.

"In 1969, it was ITT. In 1936, it was A&P (grocery stores). In 1936, A&P had more stores than Wal-Mart has right now," he said. "People thought they were going to take over the world."

Part of the Wednesday's meeting in Green Bay was the kickoff of a grass-roots effort to reach out to individuals and families who may not otherwise be active in politics to "change the nature of the debate on issues in the 2006 elections."

Among the speakers was Jim Jontz, a former representative from Indiana who now heads up the Working Families Win Campaign. That campaign is a joint effort of by Wisconsin Citizen Action and Americans for Democratic Action Education Fund.

"This is about fighting back, and to fight back we've got to get involved," Jontz said.

When given the opportunity to express concerns about the economy several people spoke up, citing high health-care costs, a declining middle class and new jobs that don't pay as much as jobs that have been sent overseas.

"It seems like the average concerns of working Americans get set aside," Jontz said.

Both Dean DeBroux of De Pere and Dan Challe of Green Bay said they would like to see those concerns come back into focus for both state and national politicians.

"I think it needs to be a higher priority," DeBroux said. "What are they doing now in the state? They're passing gun laws, gay marriage laws, all of these things that really have no effect on jobs."


Comment on this Story
The Press-Gazette's news and online staffs uses all comments we receive from this feature to help improve our news report and Web pages and provide feedback to our editors and reporters. If you also wish us to consider publishing your comments in our newspaper and on our Web site, please fill out the required fields below. An editor will contact you for a final check prior to publication. We do not publish anonymous comments.

* Required fields for verification
  Please include phone number for verification purposes if you want your comments considered for inclusion on our opinion page.


Send us a news tip | Ethics policy
Your name*:
Your email address*:
Your comments*:
Your city*:
Your phone number:
Your age*:
The Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) requires us to ask you the following question about your age.  If you have any questions about COPPA, please see our Terms of Service.
under 13 13-17 18-34 35-49 50-64 65 or older

Special Sections
Photos Photo Galleries: Multimedia
Memories - A monthly keepsake
Gallery of Homes
Home & Garden
Showcase of New Homes
Business Showcase 2005
All special sections »
All magazines »
Special Reports
Elections in Northeastern Wisconsin
Bridal Guide, January 2006
Top stories of 2005, what's ahead for 2006
Everyday Heroes in Northeastern Wisconsin
Ashwaubenon Jaguars state football journey
ShopKo Stores Inc. to be sold
All special reports »
All magazines »
 
Advanced Search

Advertising Links
Services
Dining & Drinking
Home & Garden
Medical
Attractions
Shopping
Golfing
Automotive
Lodging

Partners
Jobs: CareerBuilder.com | Cars: Cars.com | Apartments: Apartments.com | Shopping: ShopLocal.com | Weather: WFRV.com


greenbaypressgazette.com is a Gannett Company website.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, updated June 7, 2005.

Add GreenBayPressGazette.com RSS feeds
Weather | Calendar | Jobs | Cars | Apartments | Shopping | Classifieds | Dating | Subscribe | Contact Us

Company Links
Gannett   Wisinfo   USAToday  

Appleton Post-Crescent | Fond du Lac Reporter | Green Bay Press-Gazette | Manitowoc Herald Times Reporter | Marshfield News Herald
Oshkosh Northwestern | Sheboygan Press | Stevens Point Journal | Wausau Daily Herald | Wisconsin Rapids Daily Tribune